Opera is always full of such drama, sometimes as much off stage as on stage. Mary will attempt to capture some of this in her poetry, as well communicate her passion for the genre and the artists who often make it so thrilling an experience.
Biography: Mary Robertson is an Emeritus Professor in Neuropsychiatry at University College London and visiting Professor at St George’s Hospital Medical School, London. Aside from being an opera devotee, Mary is a published poet and photographer.
Rigoletto, Covent Garden July 2007
In Verdi’s great op’ra Rigoletto,
The father-daughter love was so complex,
The hunchback-jester-father scared she’ll go
From purity to sin and sordid sex,
Which was sewn in the House of Mantua,
Without love, but lust and exploitation,
With the handsome Duke, the prime wrong-doer.
Vice, vendetta, vengeance and vexation
Led to a grim curse and great tragedy,
Innocence lost, and the wrong person killed,
Revenge went wrong. All sung so brilliantly,
To rapturous music, leaving me thrilled,
Despite my tears, the tragedy and woe,
In Verdi’s great op’ra Rigoletto.
Opera Disasters Part 1
Remember teary Tosca’s trampoline,
Which bounded her back into the opra’s sky,
So what are the “funniest” I’ve ever seen?
Here is how to my dream I said “Goodbye”.
‘Twas Andrea Chenier with Domingo,
His voice froze: “Is there a doctor in the house?”
Moi! In the upper slips – with vertigo,
Despite being a shrink – I could use my nouse.
But clearly he needed an ENT
Specialist to treat those great vocal cords,
But – not a psychiatrist – sadly – not me,
So, no quick entrée to Ladies and Lords.
The man in the black tie came out again,
“The doctor’s been, Placido’s going to sing
Full of gusto, and free of all his pain!”
He flew through the op’ra on a blest wing.
Nought wrong with his voice: wish I’d had the “balls”,
As the “star’s doc”: imagine the “house calls”
Italy: A Three Day Mini Opera Tour. 24th-26th March 2009
Genoa exceeded our every expectation
The opera house and hotel were both simply gorgeous
But Milan just underwhelmed our anticipation
With hotel and late-comers making us quite nauseous
The refulgent, resplendent Nucci was fantastic
I Due Foscari – by far the opera highlight
The doomed doge, Nucci, was simply climactic,
He lost all to the Patricians’ vengeful might.
We all loved “Ah Ruggiero crudel” in Alcina,
And “La Mamma morta” in Andrea Chenier,
In Foscari the ensembles adorned La Scala
Poetry, not Alcina’s nudes, is my metier.
The scenery was a bit unhinged at La Scala,
Latecomers allowed in – half an hour late,
The bothersome glitches in Foscari and Alcina
I’ll not be going there on my next date.
Giordano’s evening was full of wonderful “can belto”
With Renato Bruson causing a great commotion,
Verdi’s, great Lucrezia echoing bel canto
In her first aria, so full of emotion.
Would I do it again? Yes, by my being “hard core”
But next time abroad I’d chose opera not star
One day, it will be “The Grand Opera Tour”:
But right now, to opera abroad a sweet: “au revoir”.
Photographs Taken at the Stage Door*
(With apologies to Ivor Gurney)
Their smiles, the triumph and laughter on show,
I missed that photo – he suddenly moved,
As in a memory only we know,
The caught smile or sigh of one beloved.
The joy of music – one of Earth’s most sacred things,
Making eyes twinkle and bright with pure joy.
The singers soar mile-high, their hearts mounts higher,
Some are grand and famous, others still coy.
Some stars are tired – no make up, often pain,
A personal rift, or opera tragedy.
Others miffed at stage door’s swinging,
But only three turned from camera and me.
I have taken super pics of Renee Fleming,
Sutherland, Carreras and Domingo.
Some were all luck, others – good timing:
Volle, Nadja Michael, DiDonato.
One of my favourites is great Bergonzi
(Aragall too, but let’s not make a list),
I’ ve been there for ages – a thrill and a duty,
And yet there are many I’m sure I have missed.
I’ve albums – some framed and some on my wall.
The photos are smiling, with their bold autographs,
I muse on the delight the singers bring us all,
The goose bumps, the tales and a few fine laughs.
(* This poem is the first in a series titled "The Ring in Poetry")
Photographs Taken at the Stage Door - 2*
Matilde di Shabran
(Royal Opera House Covent Garden, 2008)
So few make a good limerick, 
No one killed and no lunatic,
No suicide here – a good atmosphere –
An opera where none were sick.
It’s been called Beauty and the Beast;
With highest notes, it is a feast.
Women loved ‘Iron Heart’ – he played out his part,
And the ‘would be’s’ have long deceased!
Kurzack sang the greatest high E
In the loud Rondo Finale.
Florez really shone, a high echelon –
Was the set by Mr Dali?
Strong Florez sang Corradino,
Alfonso A – Isidoro,
Kursazk – Matilde: he nearly killed her,
Under the baton of ‘Carlo’.
All’s well that ends well – so they say,
Is she in love – or won, I pray?
With Mathilde’s beau – tamed Corrodino:
Mathilde is ruling the day.
(* Part of "The Ring in Poetry")
Photographs Taken at the Stage Door 3*
The Diva’s Sonnet
In early days her voice: sweet soprano,
Elizabeth , Queen in Mary Stuart.
And then a mellowed tone, golden mezzo,
As Mila’s mother, ran mad in Osud.
I heard her first in 1982:
Don Carlos – she a woman of Valois
(A Verdi lady, between me and you),
Elena in Sicillian Vespers.
She sang Desdemona, in Otello
(Atlantov loved her, but then murdered her)
She sang Trovatore with Domingo,
(Brave Leonora died for her lover).
The OBE – a voice now strong with might –
Now there’s a real star: Rosalind Plowright.
(*Part of "The Ring in Poetry")
Verdi's Requiem
Medici Choir, Sussex Gardens, London, 27 November 2004
Alessandro Manzoni fell one day,
His death, a catalyst for the long score.
Verdi’s masterpiece – his best, I’d say –
We sat in the front row, simply in awe.
The Ingemisco is always haunting,
The beautiful church was both full and warm.
The voices so soft, and then swelled to booming,
With such moving music, the magic was born.
The singing sent shivers right down my spine,
‘The wondrous sound of the trumpet rings through.
Now grant them their rest, let Heaven’s light shine,
For Libera Me, I was in tears, too,
My diagnosis was two years ago,
The cancer now gone – I love God and life so.
Photographs Taken at the Stage Door - 4*
Rest in Peace 
I’ve autographs of some stars, now long gone:
Pavarotti, Kraus, and Geraint Evans,
(As we grow older, our end is foregone),
Dame Eva, van Allen – all in heavens.
Lucia Popp was far too young to die,
The “Big C” stole her from the opera world,
Arabella and Eva – said goodbye:
As sadly her great sails were left unfurled.
The saddest for me was Jerry Hadley,
A gorgeous young man with a beaming smile,
Life was too tough – so he took his own,
Once “Fenton” in Falstaff, then volatile.
In my prayers I have a slot for those dead,
Their songs are now heard in the heav’ns instead.
(*Part of "The Ring in Poetry")
Photographs Taken at the Stage Door - 5
Il Barbiere di Siviglia – with a Difference
The night had a star-studded cast
Rosina, poor soul, in a cast,
With long golden hair, she graced her wheelchair,
But was so far from breathing her last.
One night bright with stars and the moon,
Rosina put Count in a swoon,
Florez did rejoice, as he wooed dear Joyce,
While Bartolo was a buffoon.
Now there was much joy and much peace,
Though Figaro’s antics won’t cease,
The maid kept sneezing, the opera was pleasing,
The show was a true masterpiece.
She warned: ‘The Futile Precaution’!
His fear blown out of proportion?
Rosina was sad – was Bartolo mad?
His power was like an extortion.
His “song” was from Cinderella:
The Count excelled in bravura,
Great Almaviva, sang to his Diva,
Despite a broken fibula.
I’ve heard the great DiDonato
With lilts as well as vibrato.
She made a great sound, with joy all around,
Was there a touch of... soprano?
A tyrant, a soldier, a sot,
A notary – it had the lot,
The Count wished for life with ‘Ro’ as his wife,
Bartolo may sulk: let him rot!
Photographs Taken at the Stage Door - 6
My Three Tenors
Once in the Eighties I heard a voice, 
That flowed like a dream, a Verdi tenor.
‘Twas Carlo Bergonzi – my number one choice –
A heroic man, like a father figure.
And then great Domingo entered my life,
A similar age – so I fell in love:
Had it not been for dear Marta, his wife,
Millions of women would flock round like doves.
Then came a man, youthful as a son,
A powerful voice, good looks, great acting.
Let me add praise for proud Jonas Kauffman,
The Infante he was re-enacting.
At the stage door, their smiles were fabulous,
My photographs: stunning, miraculous!
Photographs Taken at the Stage Door - 7
Turandot at the ENO 2009
I saw a fine Turandot in Verona,
And many Covent Garden productions
Where icy Turandot lives as a loner.
The one [from] The Met needs no introduction.
In all, ancient China’s tradition was the constant –
The Emperor’s bold iconography.
With dynastic memories, mythology extant,
A colourful weave of sinology.
Then I saw Goold’s production at the ENO –
Contemporary, set in a restaurant.
The reviewers slated it – it was “gung ho”,
I thought that it gave an interesting slant.
The chorus included three Elvis tributes,
Mrs Thatcher, Buddhist monks, and more than one nun.
Pensioners, Jews and waiters to boot,
And Marilyn Manson watching badminton!
The singing saved the show outright, with Liu
By Amanda Echalaz, an up-and-coming star.
She’s Tosca next year – I’ve bought seats for that, too.
Now here’s a young singer who is going far.
As for this production, what else can I say?
At least it was not a Chinese take-away!
Dreaming about the Voice of Carlo Bergonzi
I’ve heard him sing at many an opera,
I have him on vinyl and on CD.
As Alfredo in La traviata
His tenor tones are enchanting to me.
I heard his last night at Covent Garden
How great are the Forces of Destiny.
If I sound in love, I beg your pardon.
I’ve memories of him, it’s plain to see.
When visiting colleagues in Milan,
With such operatic magic all round,
It lifted our hearts as our Verdi can.
There I met his friend, and what joy I found
(I had heard him sing – a style of his own)
When he spoke to me on his telephone.
Photographs Taken at the Stage Door - 8
Duke Bluebeard's Castle (ENO 2009)
Bluebeard asks: “Where is the stage; outside or within?” 
In my mind or yours, or the outside world?
A tug-of-war between love and power, in
Marriage and relationships as yet unfurled.
Dark death, cold blood, lost souls.
Bartok and Balazs made Judith a seeker,
The castle a metaphor for erotic fantasy.
She enters this glorious, ripe adventure
With the Duke an enigmatic anomaly.
Dark death, cold blood, lost souls.
Was the castle a castle, and Bluebeard
Himself really that knight Gilles de Rais?
An evil repented (and what had he feared?),
Avoiding the fires of Hell his last days.
Dark death, cold blood, lost souls.
Could this be the story of Gilles de Rais,
Forever a grim, and a ghastly tale –
Like Fritzl, Alvares, Garrido – whose ways
(Like Bluebeard) were awful – a most evil male?
Dark death, cold blood, lost souls.
Were the seven doors seven deadly sins –
The piece a metaphor for going to hell?
Or is hell in the mind, where admission begins
Of guilt – or is it a tale Kramer had to tell?
Dark death, cold blood, lost souls.
Kramer hit the audience at the ENO.
It recoiled with words like “awful” and “shocking”
“Revolting”, “repulsive”, “couldn’t look at the show”.
But despite the horror, it was compelling.
Dark death, cold blood, lost souls.
The opera was rich in its symbolism.
Martens as Judith was quite convincing.
For me it felt doomed, with no optimism,
And the children on the stage was most worrying.
Dark death, cold blood, lost souls.
“Enjoy” would not sum up, but I’m glad I went.
Was the show of any real consequence?
Was it an intellectual or musical event,
Or was it just gratuitous violence?
Photographs Taken at the Stage Door -10
The Three Waiters
I’m usually at Covent Garden,
ENO, Royal Albert and Festival Hall.
But then I heard opera – I beg your pardon –
Again - when I went to the Mayoral Ball.
You may love Placido Domingo,
José Carreras and Pavarotti.
Now for Kauffman, I’d call out, “Oh bravo!”
Arlango or Villazon, I’d shout for with glee.
First “La Donna I Mobile” from Rigoletto,
Escammillo’s “Toreador” with all his might.
Calaf’s World Cup “Nessun Dorma” stole the show
Then great “O sole mio”, “That’s Amore”, “Tonight”.
I’ve criticised operas in this very year:
Bluebeard’s violence, Turandot’s crazy production.
But The Three Waiters brought everyone cheer –
I’m happy indeed with great “singing seduction”.
Photographs Taken at the Stage Door - 11
A Few Knights at the Opera* 1984 - 2009
I’ve spent a few nights at the opera now
Sir Thomas Allen is known for his looks,
He was once 'Mister' – now I have to bow
As I want to stay within his good books.
Sir John Tomlinson – now there’s quite a man -
With his silver hair in a ponytail.
Of this singer I’ll remain a fan
His powerful bass rocks the Richter Scale.
Sir Willard White leaves everyone behind.
A touch of an accent leaves one guessing,
His voice and manners a gentleman's - refined.
To opera and concert – he’s been a blessing.
I’ve taken all their photos, then and now,
We’re all growing old together, somehow.
(Apologies to Sir Rudolf Bing)
ANXIETY AT THE OPERA
(Die Meistersinger Dress Rehearsal) 
Welsh National Opera, Cardiff, 16th June 2010
I’ve not had the usual “peer review”
As this is just between me and you
I was anxious at the opera yesterday
Serves me right – you are sure to say
I was “press at the WNO”
All excited and then – Oh No!
I sat in the same row as Clive Barda
A friend of Zoe Dominic – and many other
I was the “new boy on the block”
I just hope you don’t say – “stick to being a doc”!
FIESCO FIASCO
Royal Opera House, Covent Garden 13th & 15th July 2010 
Poor Furlanetto’s voice faded with a sore throat
So, Sir John Tom sang so well “in the wings”
Then Paata B kept everything afloat
As Placebo Domingo cures anyone who sings!
Normal 0 false false false EN-GB X-NONE X-NONE MicrosoftInternetExplorer4 /* Style Definitions */ table.MsoNormalTable {mso-style-name:"Table Normal"; mso-tstyle-rowband-size:0; mso-tstyle-colband-size:0; mso-style-noshow:yes; mso-style-priority:99; mso-style-qformat:yes; mso-style-parent:""; mso-padding-alt:0cm 5.4pt 0cm 5.4pt; mso-para-margin:0cm; mso-para-margin-bottom:.0001pt; mso-pagination:widow-orphan; font-size:11.0pt; font-family:"Calibri","sans-serif"; mso-ascii-font-family:Calibri; mso-ascii-theme-font:minor-latin; mso-fareast-font-family:"Times New Roman"; mso-fareast-theme-font:minor-fareast; mso-hansi-font-family:Calibri; mso-hansi-theme-font:minor-latin; mso-bidi-font-family:"Times New Roman"; mso-bidi-theme-font:minor-bidi;}
A DISAPPOINTING NIGHT AT THE OPERA?
MACBETH AT THE MARIINSKY THEATRE - 25.02.2011
The staging looked tired, the production seemed old,
The same for some ten years (or so I was told)
The set had shrunk, or the stage had grown bigger,
You should check it out: dear Mr McVicar.
Great Macduff and Banquo were the best singers,
Some of the others shrill, or just beginners,
Macbeth did well, but seemed old for a debut,
Others past their prime (just between me and you).
The bar at the interval was such a “Rip”
With the warm sparkling wine – at three quid a sip!
The audience was bad, with far too much talking,
Add insult to injury – their cell phones were ringing.
Despite the “big freeze”, I went to the stage door,
I think you can now call me “really hard core”
Outside it was cold - at minus fifteen degrees,
But with my smart new mink hat, I felt the “bees knees”.
Banquo (Nikitin) was great (but tattooed to the hilt),
He was pleasant, had a nice smile and also well built,
Maestro (Gavriel Heine) really saved the day,
With great music, and charming, what else can I say?
I’m a true “Verdi girl” and quite easy to please,
But many a matter made me feel ill at ease,
I’ll say again - Maestro Heine saved the day,
But ‘twas not a Russian – from the US of A.
A DISAPPOINTING NIGHT AT THE OPERA?
(MACBETH AT THE MARINSKY THEATRE - 25.02.2011)
The staging looked tired, the production seemed old,
The same for some ten years (or so I was told)
The set had shrunk, or the stage had grown bigger,
You should check it out: dear Mr McVicar.
Great Macduff and Banquo were the best singers,
Some of the others shrill, or just beginners,
Macbeth did well, but seemed old for a debut,
Others past their prime (just between me and you).
The bar at the interval was such a “Rip”
With the warm sparkling wine – at three quid a sip!
The audience was bad, with far too much talking,
Add insult to injury – their cell phones were ringing.
Despite the “big freeze”, I went to the stage door,
I think you can now call me “really hard core”
Outside it was cold - at minus fifteen degrees,
But with my smart new mink hat, I felt the “bees knees”.
Banquo (Nikitin) was great (but tattooed to the hilt),
He was pleasant, had a nice smile and also well built,
Maestro (Gavriel Heine) really saved the day,
With great music, and charming, what else can I say?
I’m a true “Verdi girl” and quite easy to please,
But many a matter made me feel ill at ease,
I’ll say again - Maestro Heine saved the day,
But ‘twas not a Russian – from the US of A.
Mary M Robertson February 2011



thing to say about this recording is that one needs to put out of one’s mind most of the famous recordings that have preceded it since what one is accustomed to hear from the Callas, Sutherland, Caballé recordings or even further back excerpts from Cigna or Ponselle is a radically different work of art. Giovanni Antonini, Riccardo Minasi and Maurizio Biondihave spent years scraping away the barnacles of dubious performance tradition and updated instrumentation and restoring hundreds of small cuts that have become part of the standard performing edition. As with a restored oil painting the removal of years of accumulation has revealed a very different work of art. Indeed I would say that it redefines the work both in terms of sound and in appropriate casting.
attended Sunday’s “Flórez and Friends” concert at the Barbican – as opposed to sitting through oceans of orchestral filler in the RFH in order to dribble over the unfeasible length of Jonas Kaufmann’s ‘Wälse’ – you may be forgiven for wondering how an audience already in a state of chronic, uncritical delight could possibly be pleasured any more. In which case, you needed to be at tonight’s solo recital, the latest tranche of Juan Diego Flórez’s Barbican residency, which comprehensively proved the time-honoured adage “it ain’t over until the sooty-lashed one sings at least four encores”. The nubile bounced around, whooping; the mature squirmed with satisfaction in their seats, emitting the odd low moan; I shouldn’t be at all surprised if the lame weren’t seen dancing in the aisles, and the dead – always a fair percentage of any opera audience – weren’t newly-risen. Indeed, anyone suffering with scrofula could well have been cured merely by touching his immaculately tailored trousers (though I’m still working out how to explain this to the police).
In a pivotal scene in Verdi’s early opera, Pope Leo squares up to the defiant Attila, causing the Hun to turn tail. Here, two leading Slavic basses – Russian Ildar Abdrazakov and Bulgarian Orlin Anastassov – go head to head in the title role, but it proves to be something of an uneven contest due both to their supporting casts and the conditions in which the two performances were captured on film. Both are fairly traditionally staged and costumed, which should satisfy those pining for the days when Huns looked like Huns, but a few minutes viewing of each disc is enough to separate the wheat from the operatic chaff. In the blue corner, Arturo Gama’s production from the Mariinsky Theatre, released on its own label; in the red corner, a rudderless affair laughably attributed to director Plamen Kartaloff, recorded in the ruins of the Bulgarian fortress of Tsaverets.