Carmen: The Royal Opera, 3rd October 2009

E-mail Print PDF

‘Phew! What a scorcher!’ might well be a tabloid headline for a review of this revival of The Royal Opera’ s Carmen, and images/stories/car-2345 0148-garanca as carmen-cashmore.jpgan entirely appropriate one at that, as this first night performance was supported by The Helen Hamlyn Trust in association with The Sun, whose readers took the opportunity to purchase the heavily subsidised tickets available through the newspaper. The Royal Opera, who won an innovation award this week for its initial collaboration with The Sun to open the 2008-9 season with Don Giovanni, has been keen to repeat the exercise in attempting to open up opera to a new audience. The choice of Carmen seems ideal. No ‘fat birds in Viking helmets’ screamed The Sun’s article, (well, there’s little chance of them even in Wagner these days!) just an opera ‘packed with trollops, treachery, filthy vices and fabulous voices’. And all done to prove that opera, “thanks to The Sun, is not just for the toffs”.

I greatly enjoyed this production when it was first aired in 2006 with Anna Caterina Antonacci and Jonas Kaufmann starring in Francesca Zambello’s staging, but wondered how well it would suit Latvian mezzo Elina Garanca, back at Covent Garden following her stunning Romeo last season.

The curtain rises on a postlude to the whole opera – Don José is shown in prison, clutching the withered flower Carmen threw at him, a bit like those trailers for tv dramas which can act as a spoiler – before the action proper begins.

images/stories/car-2345 0045-  cashmore.jpg

What a contrast to last week’s Tristan! The libretto states that we are in ‘a square in Seville, with a cigarette factory and a guard house’…and that’s exactly what we get in Tanya McCallin’s stage design, dominated by burnt orange walls of the two buildings, the square complete with tree and water trough. The chorus is well deployed, considered as individuals rather than en masse, each with their own story. It could be viewed as a distraction, drawing the eye from the main action, but it gives a realistic impression of a bustling marketplace, complete with donkey ambling around and scantily-clad women washing their hair in the trough to cool down. The walls rotate to become Lillas Pastia’s inn in Act II with the addition of tables and chairs, whilst the circular aspect of one of the buildings lends itself well to being the exterior of the bullring for Act IV. Where the staging works less well, I feel, is in Act III where the presence of such set-dominating structures in the gypsy camp in the mountains strikes one as a little improbable. And why on earth does José abseil down a wall into the camp, when everyone else seems to be able to access it from the wings?! The festive costumes and Paule Constable’s effective lighting, especially in Act IV, create a credible sun-drenched Spain.

images/stories/car-2345   0150-garanca as carmen-cashmore.jpgSinging Carmen for the first time in the UK, Elina Garanca immediately surprised us by her physical appearance; dark-haired, tanned and sweaty. Fears about how her Baltic precision and coolness would cope portraying the sultry Spanish gypsy melted as she smouldered from the off, teasing and pouting her way through Act I, doing extremely suggestive things up her skirt with the flower in the Habanera before flinging it with precision at José. Where she doesn’t quite convince, however, is vocally. She has a truly beautiful voice, perfect for the bel canto repertoire, but it’s neither large enough nor ‘dirty’ enough to be a Carmen…yet. There were glimpses in the card scene of a suitable darkening of the voice which she may well develop into other parts of the role later in the run. I do hope so as there are many commendable things about her performance.

Roberto Alagna, also making his role debut at Covent Garden, really does seem to be so much more at home in French repertoire. His was, without a doubt, the performance of the night as the gullible, charming officer of the first half of the opera descended into the desperate outcast, mad with passion for his woman by the end. He retains that thrilling tenor sound which so impressed the first time I saw him in Gounod’s Romeo et Juliette many years ago. Although he came to grief on the B flat near the end of ‘La fleur que tu m'avais jetée’ (which wasn’t sung at the marked pianissimo either), it was easy to be won over by such a wonderful voice and charming stage presence.

Escamillo was Italian bass-baritone Ildebrando D’ Arcangelo, returning to the role. This time round, he looked a good deal more comfortable making his entrance on horseback, from where he delivered the first verse of the infamous Toréador song. Once again, he really looks the part – suave, macho, strutting his stuff up and down the tables of Lillas Pastia’s tavern like a model prowling the catwalk. His voice has the firmness required and it’s easy to see how Carmen is seduced. The brief scene between Escamillo and José in the gypsy camp, which can so often fall flat, bristled with tension here.

images/stories/carmen-2345 0749ccatherine ashmore.jpg

Reprising her role as Micaëla was soprano Liping Zhang. She has a small, attractive voice and it wasn’t until the latter part of her duet with José that she really hit her stride, both she and Alagna displaying honeyed tone in ‘Ô souvenirs du pays’. Her Act III aria was well phrased, although she didn’t convince that Micaëla is anything more than a wet blanket.

Conductor Bertrand de Billy was fast out of the traps, taking the Act I Prélude at a real lick, generating plenty of excitement. Throughout the evening, the orchestra played superbly, carefully nuanced playing balancing the brasher elements of Bizet’s score. At times, they appeared to be too loud, but this could well be a problem from where I was seated (front row of the balcony, left of centre). Several times the singers (never Alagna) struggled to ride the orchestra, apart from a ‘sweet spot’ stage left, around where the officers’ table is set in Act I. Garanca located this and at times her voice really did seem the right size for the role. Next week, I am seeing this from a different position in the House so will be interested to hear how well the voices project versus the orchestra then.

The smaller roles were, on the whole, well taken. I liked Vincent Ordonneau’s Le Remendado and Adrian Clarke’s Le Dancaïre, the Act II quintet delivered slickly and with panache. Eri Nakamura and Louise Innes, as Frasquita and Mercédès, were fine, if without the characterization of Elena Xanthoudakis and Viktoria Vizin who were outstanding in 2006.

I was sceptical about how many in the audience would be (a) genuine Sun readers or (b) new to the Royal Opera House. Lots of photographs being taken in the auditorium and plenty of asking for directions convinced me of the latter and their response to the performance was euphoric and heart-warming. I sincerely hope they return for other shows…though perhaps Tristan might not necessarily be a recommendable next step.

Mark Pullinger
Opera Britannia



Last Updated ( Tuesday, 13 September 2011 19:50 )  

Recent Reviews

Puccini: Tosca

Renée Fleming, our hostess with the mostest at the Metropolitan Opera’s latest cinema relay of Tosca a few weeks ago, urged us – as ever – to experience opera first-hand and to ‘come visit the Met’ or to support your local opera company. The Opera Britannia excursions budget wouldn’t get you as far as York, let alone New York, so my local company it was and performing the same opera too. Tosca is very much the safe, financial bolster to Welsh National Opera’s Tudor trilogy in its autumn season – a crowd-pleaser of a production excavated from 1992, but which seemed even older.


Humperdinck: Hänsel und Gretel

And so to Milton Keynes, pursued by a perishing wind fit to crack the famous concrete cows. The Milton Keynes Theatre, as a venue, is one of the jewels in the ATG crown, big enough to house almost any touring product, with spacious and well-designed auditorium and foyers. Unfortunately it is marooned in one of those soulless retail areas surrounded by a sea of mediocre chain outlets which offer the same tat or that which passes for food in a thousand other identical areas the world over. Whether it was position or the icy blasts which accounted for the poorly populated house is hard to say.


Mozart: The Magic Flute

For all the risk-taking in the operatic world, productions which are guaranteed bums-on-seats bankers are like Nibelung gold. To scrap not one but two such productions is a brave move for English National Opera this season. We shall see what Christopher Alden inflicts on Rigoletto in the spring, replacing Jonathan Miller’s famous Little Italy staging. Meanwhile, Nicholas Hytner’s much loved production of The Magic Flute has finally been laid to rest (after a few ‘absolutely your last chance to see’ revivals), replaced with this new one by Simon McBurney and Complicite.


Shostakovich: The Nose

Described at the time as “an anarchist’s hand grenade,” The Nosewas not well received and soon disappeared from view, although Malko, one of Shostakovich’s teachers at the Conservatoire, recognised the quality of the score. It was composed in 1927-28 and given a concert performance, against Shostakovich’s better judgment, in 1929: “The Nose loses all meaning if it is seen just as a musical composition. For the music springs only from the action...It is clear to me that a concert performance of The Nose will destroy it."



ENO goes widescreen

After resisting the prevailing tide for opera houses beaming their wares to a worldwide cinema audience, English National Opera has seen the light. From 2014, selected productions will be screened at 300 cinemas around the UK and beyond, starting with its revival of David Alden’s production of Peter Grimes, starring Stuart Skelton. A new production, by Terry Gilliam, of Berlioz’s Benvenuto Cellini will also be relayed. Gilliam’s earlier Berlioz adventure, The Damnation of Faust, was broadcast on television.



Poetry Corner

Biography: Mary Robertson is an Emeritus Professor in Neuropsychiatry at University College London and visiting Professor at St George’s Hospital Medical School, London. Aside from being an opera devotee, Mary is a published poet and photographer.

(New poems added: 04/08/2010)

more >>



News updates

Subscribe to Opera Britannia to receive all the latest news and latest reviews

Signup >>

Around the Houses

Dmitri Platanias will sing the title role when the Royal Opera revives its new production of Nabucco. Mariusz Kwiecien will be joined by Saimir Pirgu in Steffen Aarfing's production of Szymanowski's King Roger at Covent Garden in 2015. The Royal Opera will stage Andrea Chenier in 2014/15 with Jonas Kaufmann, Eva-Maria Westbroek and Željko Lucic.

Anna Netrebko is due to sing the role of Lady Macbeth for a single performance at the Bavarian State Opera in June 2014.

Maria Agresta will sing Lucrezia in Verdi's I due Foscari in the 2014-15 season at Covent Garden. Placido Domingo does the Doge double, adding the baritone role of Francesca Foscari to his Simon Boccanegra.

Corinne Winters, fresh from her triumph as Violetta in ENO's production of La traviata, is to return to the Coliseum next season as Teresa in Berlioz's Benvenuto CelliniMichael Spyres sings the title role in a production which sees the return ofTerry Gilliam to the director's seat, after his Damnation of Faust debut.

. Read More>>

"Around the Houses" concentrates on providing the latest news on future plans for opera companies around the globe, artists schedules, cancellations and interesting snippets of information. We will try and avoid unsubstantiated gossip wherever possible, but all of our sources will remain completely confidential.  If you would like to advise us about potential news for this section, then please feel free to email us at

Coming Soon

Reviews to be published shortly:



CD Reviews

Vivaldi: Catone in Utica (Naive)

Although he claimed to have composed around ninety operas, there cannot be many left in the archives of the Biblioteca Nazionale in Turin for Naïve to record in its ongoing Vivaldi Edition if you discount pasticcios, reworkings and incomplete works. Their latest offering, the fourteenth opera in the series, falls into the latter category, for only Acts II and III of Catone in Utica have survived. The opera was written to celebrate the culmination of his third and final season at Verona’s Teatro dell’Accademia Filarmonica – a profitable success for the composer. Premiered in 1737, it is unknown whether Act I was even written by Vivaldi himself, or whether music by other composers was employed.

Read more>>

Recital Reviews

Anne Sofie von Otter: Alumni Series

Milton Court, 23rd November 2013

When this was first drawn to my attention, such is my regard for the Swedish mezzo that I immediately withdrew from reviewing Albert Herring some two hundred yards down the road in the Barbican, and enthusiastically opted for what I thought was an evening of French chansons and mélodies. What a prospect! Anne Sofie von Otter let loose on Chausson and Debussy, Fauré and Poulenc, perhaps some Gounod and Bizet, with maybe a little Délibes and/or Satie by way of let-your-hair-down encore material. All with her long-term musical accompanist Bengt Forsberg summoning up the necessary style. Rapture guaranteed, for which I arrived fully prepared.

Read more>>

DVD Reviews

Donizetti: Lucrezia Borgia (EuroArts)

Scholars now doubt on Lucrezia Borgia’s credentials as mass poisoner, but Donizetti’s operatic treatment on her historical character would have us believe she spiked drinks with cantarella and laced dishes with deadly nightshade like nobody’s business. Lucrezia, here on her fourth marriage (in reality, her third) to Alfonso d’Este, Duke of Ferrara, is reunited with Gennaro, her long-lost son. Unfortunately, she withholds this vital information from him and from her husband, who suspects her of conducting an affair. It’s as free an interpretation as the lusty television series The Borgias, which never got as far as this in Lucrezia’s marital history, but none the worse for that.

Read more>>

Copyright 09 Opera Britannia
facebook twitter